Reading Recommendation
I'm in the middle of reading a book by Mel Levine, M.D. titled "The Myth of Laziness". It's main thesis is that some students (and adults) have output failure that manifests itself as apparrent laziness. But that what is really happening is some sort of hidden disability that is preventing a person from succeeding at whatever they need to get done. It is a really interesting idea; it takees the concept of learning disability and applies it to all sorts of learning breakdowns.
I found the book hopeful at times, but also depressing at other times. Dr. Levine uses detailed anecdotal evidence to illustrate these diabilities and how they appear. He provides strategies for parents and educators to try to help these kids (and sometimes adults), but also, there is the problem hanging over every situation: how is this person going to cope with the demands of life if they have, for example, a problem formulating a complete sentence in oral or written form? We can work with this person, "demystify" their disability, and steer them away from a career in courtroom litigation, but what else? I find that very sad.
But I also see, in his examples and descriptions, students that I have had. Their poor handwriting (probably graphomotor dysfunction), unfixable spelling, poor organization/time management skills. And I think, "I can teach English to these people for a year, and they still wont get it, because of whatever learning problem put them here in the first place." This book is definitely going to change the way I see my students the next time I teach a class.
I found the book hopeful at times, but also depressing at other times. Dr. Levine uses detailed anecdotal evidence to illustrate these diabilities and how they appear. He provides strategies for parents and educators to try to help these kids (and sometimes adults), but also, there is the problem hanging over every situation: how is this person going to cope with the demands of life if they have, for example, a problem formulating a complete sentence in oral or written form? We can work with this person, "demystify" their disability, and steer them away from a career in courtroom litigation, but what else? I find that very sad.
But I also see, in his examples and descriptions, students that I have had. Their poor handwriting (probably graphomotor dysfunction), unfixable spelling, poor organization/time management skills. And I think, "I can teach English to these people for a year, and they still wont get it, because of whatever learning problem put them here in the first place." This book is definitely going to change the way I see my students the next time I teach a class.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home